It so happened that USA Today published its report the day before the Oklahoma Asset Building Coalition held the first of five regional meetings around the state. These gathering are bringing together a diverse group of stakeholders to talk about  challenges facing low- and moderate-income Oklahomans and strategies for achieving economic security. The meeting began with a presentation on the Oklahoma Self-Sufficiency Standard, a tool for calculating the amount of income that families of different sizes and compositions need to meet their basic household expenses – housing, food, child care, transportation, health care, taxes and miscellaneous – without public or private support or subsidies. For a single working adult with one infant and one preschool child, the hourly self-sufficiency wage is $16.43 an hour in Cherokee County and over $21.63 an hour in Tulsa County. For a two-parent family with kids that age, each working adult would need to make $10.28 an hour in Cherokee County and $12.39 an hour in Tulsa to meet its basic needs. It’s worth mentioning that this is a basic family budget with an austere set of assumptions – it includes no meals out or entertainment, no one-time purchases, no loan payments or money put aside for savings.

It’s obvious that for many working Oklahomans, there is a substantial gap between the actual wages paid by available jobs and the self-sufficiency standard. As jobs have disappeared and wage growth has collapsed over the course of the recession, the gap has certainly widened and more families have fallen into it. However, well before the downturn started, and presumably long after it ends, adults may work full-time and make the best possible decisions about how to budget their money and yet still fall short of making end meet without some form of ongoing help.

There are at least two major implications that can be drawn from the Self-Sufficiency Standard.  The first is that for this population of working families whose income falls short of self-sufficiency, identified sometimes as the working poor, access to public programs like Medicaid, food stamps, child care subsidies and rental assistance provide the critical supports that maintain family health and well-being. Research by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities has found that public safety net programs have cut the number of Americans living in poverty by nearly half, reduced the severity of poverty for those who remain poor, and helped protect Americans from the deepest extremes of poverty. As we discussed in this blog post, key parts of the safety net are seriously frayed, but for those who qualify, public benefit programs are frequently what allow low- and moderate-income working families to pay the bills and take care of basic needs from one month to the next.

Yet for families to get ahead, it will take more than public benefits and income supports. The second implication of the Self-Sufficiency Standard is the need for strategies focused on helping families achieve economic security.The Oklahoma Asset Building Coalition has chosen to focus on building and preserving assets as a key cornerstone and pathway. As OK Policy argued in a recent brief:

For individuals and families aiming to achieve economic success, the key to prosperity is the development and accumulation of assets. Assets are the basic foundations for financial security and the pathway to the American Dream.

Over the course of our remaining upcoming meetings, which will be held in Durant, Lawton, Oklahoma City and Woodward over the month of September, the Coalition will continue the work of identifying practices, programs and policies that can make a difference in building and protecting assets and expanding economic security. If you are interested in attending one of the meetings, click here for a schedule and registration information. Or click here to join the Oklahoma Assets Google group where you can share information, news, resources and questions related to asset building strategies and policies.

share this post

“I’m scared spotless,” Mason, a homeowner, said. Given only two months’ severance, she pulled some money from her retirement account, canceled her YMCA membership and other nonessentials from her budget, is working a temporary job and looking like crazy for employment…

“I don’t want to lose my house, want to pay my bills and keep up my insurance,” she said.

The same day, The New York Times ran an opinion column by Barbara Ehrenreich, the author of the 2001 memoir Nickled and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America. Ehrenreich revisits some of the low-wage workers and communities she profiled in her book and finds that, while the media has tended to focus on the emergence of the “nouveau poor” among those who were previously affluent before the recent economic collapse, for the “already poor” and the “always poor”, this recession has been especially tough.  She cites data showing that blue-collar unemployment is increasing three times as quickly as white-collar unemployment, which is pushing many people who were already scraping to get by during the good times right off the cliff of financial stability.

The recession of the ’80s transformed the working class into the working poor, as manufacturing jobs fled to the third world, forcing American workers into the low-paying service and retail sector. The current recession is knocking the working poor down another notch — from low-wage employment and inadequate housing toward erratic employment and no housing at all.

Ehrenreich’s largely anecdotal stories are less of people rendered homeless than of overcrowding – families doubling or tripling up in crowded apartments, trailers, and mobile homes, moving in with parents, children, and more distant relatives, or camping out on couches and floors. Living in cramped and overcrowded quarters is stressful for all involved, and is cited, in combination with unemployment, as one of the causes of a reported spike in cases of domestic violence in many parts of the country.

Cindy Mason, featured in The Oklahoman article, states that, “I can’t even listen to the news anymore because I can’t hear what is said about unemployment.” Reading and listening to the stories about Cindy and others in circumstances like her’s isn’t easy and doesn’t offer any solutions, but at least offers us important glimpses into the real struggles that families are facing during these difficult days.

share this post