Please don’t feed the stereotypes

This is an expanded and revised version of an op-ed that ran in The Oklahoman.

Photo by U.S. Department of Agriculture / CC BY 2.0
Photo by U.S. Department of Agriculture / CC BY 2.0

The Oklahoma Republican Party recently ignited a local and national firestorm with a Facebook post pointing out a so-called irony of signs in national parks warning that feeding animals can create dependence on handouts at a time when a growing number of Americans are receiving federal food stamp benefits.

The post, which was later deleted, displayed a callous and mistaken understanding of the food stamp program and the people it serves. The program, now known as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, is among the most effective ways that the United States helps hard-pressed families to stay afloat and ensure they can afford enough to eat.

SNAP’s main purpose is to increase the food purchasing power of eligible low-income households in order to alleviate hunger and malnutrition. As its name suggests, the program is intended to supplement other sources of income, rather than cover a household’s entire food budget. In 2014, the average participating individual in Oklahoma received $122 in monthly benefits, or about $4 a day, according to data from the Oklahoma Department of Human Services.

Currently in Oklahoma, just over 600,000 people receive SNAP benefits each month and close to 900,000, or nearly one in four Oklahomans, receive assistance at some point during the year. Of these, the vast majority are low-income seniors, people with chronic disabilities, or children. The smallest category of recipients are working-age adults without dependent children and without a disability, who are limited to three months of benefits while unemployed before being subject to a 20-hour-per-week work requirement. Just 2 percent of the SNAP population in Oklahoma falls under this category, according to DHS.

SNAP&Work ParticipationContrary to the stereotypes expressed by the Facebook post, SNAP has become quite effective in supporting work, not undermining it. “The overwhelming majority of SNAP recipients who can work do so,” noted the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities in a 2013 study of the labor force participation of SNAP benefits.  Among SNAP households with at least one working-age, able-bodied adult, more than half work – and more than 80 percent work in the year prior to or the year after receiving SNAP. The rates are even higher for families with children.

“It is not moral failure or government bureaucracy run amok that is causing Oklahoma’s high SNAP enrollment…It is that our economy is not creating enough good-paying, full-time jobs to allow families and individuals to get by without support”

The fact that so many working families still need help to buy food tells us it is not moral failure or government bureaucracy run amok that is causing Oklahoma’s high SNAP enrollment. Rather it is that our economy is not creating enough good-paying, full-time jobs to allow families and individuals to get by without support. In a two-parent household with two children, for example, both adults must earn $13.55 per hour working full-time to meet their basic expenses without assistance in the Oklahoma City area, according to the MIT Living Wage calculator. That is far above the hourly wage for most service sector jobs, as well as many blue-collar jobs in other sectors. Even in state government, low pay and wage freezes have left up to 30 percent of corrections officers eligible for food stamps, according to Oklahoma House Speaker Jeff Hickman.  Overall, nearly one in every three jobs in Oklahoma is in an occupation where the median annual pay is below the poverty level for a family of four ($23,283).

So many low-paying jobs and underemployment are why SNAP participation levels have barely fallen from their highest levels during the deep recession of 2008-2010. Community food banks and local food pantries and soup kitchens similarly report sustained high need for their services, even as the state’s overall economy has improved. Oklahoma’s uneven recovery is leaving many families behind.

Rather than spreading false stereotypes about those Oklahomans who benefit from public safety net programs, we should be focused on creating more opportunities for workers to earn a decent living. Raising the minimum wage and boosting overtime protections, as well as investing more in quality education and job training, are indispensable parts of this strategy.

Still, while unemployment and underemployment, stagnant wages, and myriad personal and family challenges leave many Oklahomans earning too little to get by, the safety net is succeeding in keeping many afloat.  A recent report from the Center of Budget and Policy Priorities found that thanks to SNAP, the poverty rate was reduced to 10.5 percent for all Oklahomans from 14.3 percent and to 10.2 percent for children from 17.7 percent. Social Security and refundable tax credits for low-income working families also have a major impact in lifting family incomes above the poverty level.

Beyond all the data, the insensitive food stamp comment raises more fundamental questions about how we treat the less fortunate. It so happened that the controversy erupted on July 14th, the birth date of native son Woody Guthrie. In the second-to-last verse of his most famous and beloved song, This Land is Your Land, Guthrie asked a question and posed a challenge that still resonate with a deep moral urgency today:

In the shadow of the steeple I saw my people,
By the relief office I seen my people;
As they stood there hungry, I stood there asking
Is this land made for you and me?

Learn More // Do More

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Former Executive Director David Blatt joined OK Policy in 2008 and served as its Executive Director from 2010 to 2019. He previously served as Director of Public Policy for Community Action Project of Tulsa County and as a budget analyst for the Oklahoma State Senate. He has a Ph.D. in political science from Cornell University and a B.A. from the University of Alberta. David has been selected as Political Scientist of the Year by the Oklahoma Political Science Association, Local Social Justice Champion by the Dan Allen Center for Social Justice, and Public Citizen of the Year by the National Association of Social Workers.

2 thoughts on “Please don’t feed the stereotypes

  1. Not sure there is enough room for me to write all of this but I will see. I’m sitting here just steaming over the SNAP program. I am a senior that work for 25 years before being diagnosed with breast cancer. Now I am on disability raising a 17 year old and receiving 15.00 a month in food stamps. My FIXED income is not enough to pay my rent, utilities, car insurance, car payment and groceries. I find it shaming that I am in this situation and have to beg for benefits along with being ridiculed by the general public because I’m on welfare. Every day I listen to people gripe because they feel they are having to foot the bill for people that refuse to work. Some days I wish I could crawl in a hole and die. Trust me my daughter doesn’t feel any better. Because you people that try to keep up with the Jones’ and buy your kids all of the name brand products, games and whatever, it makes the common kid feel like crap! I could go on but I’m sure this will not even be read by anyone!

  2. I read it Barbara (Whiteaker), and I empathize. You mention the Jones and the people who try to keep up with them. I will bet a month’s pay they call themselves Christians, yet their attitudes are anything but! Keep your chin up and be proud. You have lead a productive, honorable life. Let no one make you feel less of a person than what God created you, same for your daughter. Please send your note to the editor of the newspaper. If you won’t do it for yourself, do it for all the others in this state you are also in your shoes. Fight the ignorance.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.